Document Type

Article

Publication Date

9-26-2017

Publication Title

Social Medicine

Volume

11

Issue

3

First page number:

98

Last page number:

107

Abstract

In 2014, almost 10 years after the 2005 International Consensus Conference on Intersex in Chicago,1 one of the conference co-organisers, under the auspices of a number of international paediatric endocrinology societies, launched the Global DSD Update to assess progress. A consortium of fourteen work groups conducted online/email discussions to explore each of the fourteen key topics, one of which was use of the controversial medical umbrella term ‘Disorders of Sex Development (DSD)’. The initial key question for Work Group 1 (referred to hereafter as WG1) was to reconsider the nomenclature. Nineteen individuals from a variety of professional backgrounds, including medical practitioners, patient advocates, academics and psychologists, accepted invitations to contribute. This article is based on a transcript of the 6-month debate, collated using thematic analysis methods. Seven key themes were identified: a) Disorder of Sex Development – What does this mean? b) How useful is the word ‘Disorder’? c) How useful is the word ‘Sex’? d) Benevolent non-disclosure of terminology e) How useful is an umbrella term? f) The issue of evidence and g) Considerations for future nomenclature. This article also highlights the challenges in debating issues that straddle the medico-social interface, such as terminology, and between participants coming from different professional disciplines and epistemological standpoints. While recognising that such discussions can be useful and enlightening for all parties, this article recommends that a shared frame of reference be agreed by all stakeholders from the outset in order to provide a more fruitful basis for discussion.

Keywords

Nomenclature; Terminology; DSD; Disorder; Intersex; CARD

Disciplines

Gender and Sexuality | Medicine and Health Sciences | Social and Behavioral Sciences

File Format

PDF

File Size

249 Kb

Language

English

Download


Search your library

Share

COinS